The biggest mistake most first-time visitors make is building an itinerary around a list of cities rather than around a feeling. Italy is not a checklist. It's a country where the best moments tend to happen between the sights – in a trattoria with no English menu, on a ferry crossing a lake at dusk, in a piazza at 10pm when half the town is still outside. The more you leave room for that, the better the trip.
Start by picking a region, not a highlights reel. Italy's geography means that genuine variety – coast, hills, cities, food culture – is available within almost any single region. Tuscany alone offers medieval hilltowns, Renaissance art, beach resorts and some of the world's best wine, all within a two-hour drive. Puglia covers baroque architecture, prehistoric trulli, white sandy beaches and a food tradition unlike anything else in Italy. Sicily is practically a country in its own right. You don't need to cross the whole peninsula to have a complete trip.
Think seriously about timing. May and June are the best all-around months for Italy: the light is extraordinary, temperatures are warm without being overwhelming, and the most popular sites are far easier to navigate than in high summer. September is the other sweet spot – the sea is still warm, the crowds thin out after the first week, and the food calendar peaks with grape harvests, truffle season and sagre in almost every region. July and August work best in the north – the Lakes, the Dolomites, the cooler Tuscan coast – and less well in the cities, which become genuinely exhausting in the heat.
Plan your transport before you plan your hotels. Italy's train network is excellent between major cities – Rome to Naples takes just over an hour on the high-speed line, Florence to Venice is under two hours. But the south and the islands require a different approach: a car is almost essential in Puglia, Calabria and rural Sicily, and on Sardinia it's the only way to reach the best beaches. Knowing how you're moving determines where it makes sense to stay.
Book direct, and book early. For summer travel to the Amalfi Coast, Sardinia and Taormina, the best properties fill up three to six months in advance. Every Hotiday property is available at the best price when you book through our site. Members receive an additional 5% off instantly at checkout.